Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire & Rescue Services (HMICFRS) independently assesses the effectiveness and efficiency of police forces. 

One of the ways it does this is through the PEEL annual assessment which all forces are subjected to.  Forces are assessed on their effectiveness, efficiency and legitimacy and graded as outstanding, good, requires improvement or inadequate.      

Police and Crime Commissioners have a legal duty to respond to reports produced by HMICFRS for their force; national reports (PEEL or thematic); and joint inspection reports which are published by HMICFRS.

Listed below are details of recent HMICFRS inspections and reports and, where relevant, a response from the PCC.

2021

Month Report PCC's response
September Interim report: Inspection into how effectively the police engage with women and girls - HMICFRS (justiceinspectorates.gov.uk) Inspection into how effectively the police engage with women and girls.docx
June HMICFRS- Policing in the Pandemic.pdf HMICFRS- Policing in the Pandemic.pdf
May   HMICFRS: An Inspection of the effectiveness of the Regional Organised Crime Units  /   PCC response to effectiveness of the Regional Organised Crime Unit
April Getting the balance right an inspection of how effectively the police deal with protests PCC Response to HMICFRS report Getting The Balance Right.pdf
January Criminal Justice Joint Inspection: Impact of the pandemic on the Criminal Justice System PCC Response to: ‘Impact of the pandemic on the Criminal Justice System’

2020

Month Report PCC's response
December

HMICFRS - Pre-charge bail and released under investigation:  Striking a balance

PCC Response to: ‘Pre-charge bail and released under investigation:  Striking a balance’
 

Safe to share? Report on Liberty and Southall Black Sister’s super-complaint on policing and immigration status

 PCC Response to: ‘Safe to share? Report on Liberty and Southall Black Sister’s super-complaint on policing and immigration status’
November  HMICFRS - An inspection of the National Crime Agency’s relationship with regional organised crime units PCC Response to: ‘An inspection of the National Crime Agency’s relationship with regional organised crime units’
July HMICFRS - PEEL spotlight report: The Hard Yards: Police-to-police collaboration PCC response to: 'PEEL spotlight report: The Hard Yards: Police-to-police collaboration'
  HMICFRS - Roads Policing: Not optional: An inspection of roads policing in England and Wales PCC response to 'Roads Policing: Not optional: An inspection of roads policing in England and Wales'
  HMICFRS - A call for help: Police contact management through call handling and control rooms in 2018/19 PCC response to 'A call for help: Police contact management through call handling and control rooms in 2018/19' 
  State of Policing: The Annual Assessment of Policing in England and Wales 2019 PCC response to 'State of Policing: The Annual Assessment of Policing in England and Wales 2019'
March HMICFRS - Counter-Terrorism Policing: An inspection of the police's contribution to the government's Prevent programme PCC response to 'Counter-Terrorism Policing: An inspection of the police's contribution to the government's Prevent programme' 
February CJJI - A joint thematic inspection of Integrated Offender Management PCC response to: 'A joint thematic inspection of Integrated Offender Management'
  HMICFRS PEEL Spotlight Report: Diverging under pressure PCC response to: 'PEEL Spotlight Report: Diverging under pressure'
  HMICFRS - National Child Protection Inspections: 2019 thematic report PCC response to 'National Child Protection Inspections: 2019 thematic report' 
  The multi-agency response to child sexual abuse in the family environment PCC response to 'The multi-agency response to child sexual abuse in the family environment' 
January CJJI - Evidence led domestic abuse prosecutions PCC response to 'Evidence led domestic abuse prosecutions' 
  HMICRF - Both sides of the coin: The police and National Crime Agency's response to vulnerable in 'county lines' drug offending  PCC response to 'Both sides of the coin: The police and National Crime Agency's response to vulnerable people in 'county lines' drug offending'

2019

Month Report PCC's response
December N/A  
November N/A  
October HMICFRS - Cyber: keep the light on - an inspection of the police response to cyber-dependent crime PCC response to Cyber: keep the light on - an inspection of the police response to cyber-dependent crime
September HMICFRS Shining a light on betrayal: Abuse of position for a sexual purpose PCC response to Shining a light on betrayal: Abuse of position for a sexual purpose
August N/A  
July HMCPSI & HMICFRS - The poor relation: The police and CPS response to crimes against older people PCC response to 'The poor relation: the police and CPS response to crimes against older people'
June N/A  
May HMICFRS PEEL Inspection - Wiltshire May 2019 Response to the 2019 HMICFRS Inspection from the Chief and the PCC 
April HMICFRS Sussex Police response to stalking and harassment PCC response - stalking and harassment
  HMICFRS - an inspection of the police response to fraud PCC response - an inspection of police response to fraud
March N/A  
February Summary of HMICFRS Programme and framework, Feb 2019  
  HMICFRS - police response to domestic abuse - an update PCC response - domestic abuse - an update
January HMICFRS - public perceptions of policing in England and Wales  

2018

2019 PEEL Inspection Response

2019 PEEL assessment for Wiltshire

2017

HMICFRS 2017 Summary page

PEEL Effectiveness 2017

PCC Response to PEEL Effectiveness report

PEEL Legitimacy 2017

PEEL Efficiency 2017

Crime Data Integrity Inspection

2016

HMICFRS Summary report 2016

PEEL Effectiveness 2016

PEEL Legitimacy 2016

PEEL Efficiency 2016

Joint targeted area inspection of the multi-agency response to abuse and neglect in Wiltshire

Joint Inspection of Police Custody

Best Use of Stop and Search

2015

HMICFRS Summary report 2015

PEEL Effectiveness 2015

PEEL Legitimacy 2015

PEEL Efficiency 2015

2014

PEEL assessment 2014